The National Consumer Tribunal has fined Bryanston Executive Cars CC R500 000 for misleading a customer and including unlawful clauses in its sales agreements. The dealership attempted to bypass the Consumer Protection Act by explicitly stating that no six-month warranty was provided on a second-hand vehicle. The business has 30 business days to pay the penalty into the National Revenue Fund.
The case stems from the sale of a 2012 Mercedes-Benz C350 for R228 935 in August 2024. The buyer travelled from Durban to collect the car, but later reported multiple issues, including faulty headlights, steering problems, a leaking sunroof and a broken radiator. The customer also noted that the vehicle lacked a navigation system, which was part of the original advertisement.
Why did the Tribunal issue the R500 000 fine?
The Tribunal determined that the dealership misled the buyer through its advertising and failed to clarify the actual condition of the vehicle. The sales contract contained illegal clauses designed to limit the consumer's rights.
- Stating in the contract that "No 6-month warranty is given or implied".
- Using terms and conditions intentionally drafted to defeat the purposes of the Consumer Protection Act.
- Failing to correct the buyer's false impression created by the vehicle's advertisement.
The Tribunal noted that this was not the dealership's first offence. The business previously received a R100 000 fine in June 2024 for violating the Consumer Protection Act. The Tribunal stated that this repeated behaviour showed a disregard for consumer rights.
Why were the repair costs not refunded?
Despite the fine, the Tribunal did not order the dealership to refund the purchase price or reimburse the buyer for specific repair costs. The consumer had spent R10 235 to fix the leaking sunroof and R14 180 to replace the radiator.
The dealership argued that the car passed a roadworthy test two days before delivery and that the buyer had inspected and test-driven it. The business also stated that the customer arranged his own repairs without giving the dealership a chance to inspect and resolve the reported faults.
The Tribunal agreed with this defence regarding the repair costs. It ruled that the buyer failed to prove the radiator and sunroof defects were present at the time of sale. The consumer also did not provide the dealership an opportunity to address the mechanical issues before paying for independent repairs.

A rating and a few words will help other readers