The South Gauteng High Court has ordered the City of Johannesburg to reverse a R214 916.48 water bill because the debt had expired. In a judgment delivered on 17 November 2026, the court ruled that the municipality waited too long to claim the money for consumption charges dating from March 2017 to September 2019.
The legal dispute involved a property company that bought a property in December 2006 and opened its own municipal account in June 2007. The municipality mistakenly continued billing water consumption to the previous owner's account while the new owner paid its own bills.
Following an October 2021 court order to reconcile the accounts, the municipality demanded the R214 916.48 in March 2022. It unilaterally debited this amount from the company's account in September 2022 and launched a court application to recover the funds in April 2023.
When do municipal water and electricity debts prescribe?
Under the Prescription Act, ordinary debts such as municipal water and electricity charges lapse three years from the date they become due. The court stated that a municipality cannot delay the start of this three-year period by failing to issue invoices on time and presenting a backdated bill later.
Because the municipality is the water service provider, it is considered to have known about the consumption when it occurred. The court found that the latest charges had prescribed by November 2022, making the April 2023 court claim at least five months too late.
What the court ordered the municipality to do
The court directed the City of Johannesburg to immediately reverse the R214 916.48 debit and any related charges from the company's municipal account. The judge declared that the company is not liable for the old charges.
The court rejected several legal arguments from the municipality, including claims that:
- The property company failed to properly raise prescription as a defence.
- An R84 032.87 payment made in March 2020 acted as an acknowledgment of debt. The judge ruled that paying undisputed current charges does not mean accepting liability for a separate disputed debt.
The judge ordered the municipality to pay legal costs on a punitive attorney-and-client scale, noting that it should have known the debt had prescribed instead of wasting court time.

A rating and a few words will help other readers